Evaluates one short defeasible argument by classifying it as a stereotyped reasoning scheme (appeal to expert opinion, analogy, sign, cause to effect, consequences, popular practice, slippery slope, practical reasoning), instantiating the scheme's premise slots to expose its implicit premises, then
Evaluates one short defeasible argument by classifying it as a stereotyped reasoning scheme (appeal to expert opinion, analogy, sign, cause to effect, consequences, popular practice, slippery slope, practical reasoning), instantiating the scheme's premise slots to expose its implicit premises, then putting that scheme's keyed critical questions to it and rendering a presumption verdict that stands